Hail Damage Claim

St. Paul Hail Damage Case Study

Back to case studies

The Situation

A commercial office property in St. Paul sustained significant hail damage after a severe storm impacted the flat roofing system and multiple exterior components. While the initial carrier inspection recognized some storm-related damage, the full scope of loss was not properly evaluated. The insurance company issued an initial offer of just $14,500. That amount did not reflect the true extent of membrane damage, flashing-related issues, moisture intrusion concerns, or code-related roofing items necessary to properly restore the property.

What the Insurance Company Missed

Roof membrane bruising and functional hail impacts were treated as minor or cosmetic only

Moisture intrusion indicators were not fully included in the original scope

HVAC curb flashing and parapet-related damage were overlooked

Code-required flat roofing installation and replacement items were excluded

The overall roof-system scope was undervalued after a limited inspection

The Resolution

A more complete hail damage review was performed after the property owner sought professional advocacy. That inspection documented functional damage across the flat roofing system, identified omitted exterior components, and rebuilt the estimate around the true cost of restoring the property.

Slope-by-slope hail impact documentation strengthened the damage record

Membrane bruising and compromised roofing sections were added to the scope

Moisture-related damage indicators supported a broader restoration need

HVAC curb flashing, parapet details, and accessory damage were restored to the estimate

Code-related roofing requirements were included in the revised claim presentation

With stronger documentation, a fuller roof-system analysis, and a more complete claim scope, the settlement increased to $40,970. The revised outcome helped fund proper commercial roof restoration instead of leaving the property owner underpaid for a compromised roofing system.

Impact by the Numbers

The Functional Hail Damage Problem

Hail claims are often undervalued when insurers focus too narrowly on visible surface conditions and fail to evaluate whether the roofing system has sustained functional damage. On flat and low-slope commercial roofs, membrane bruising, flashing damage, accessory impacts, and moisture intrusion can materially change the true cost of restoration. In this case, the original estimate missed several roofing-system issues that affected the actual scope of loss. Once those items were documented in greater detail, the claim value changed significantly.

Key Takeaways

Hail claims are often underestimated when functional damage is labeled cosmetic

Membrane bruising and compromised roofing sections were added to the scope

Moisture-related damage indicators supported a broader restoration need

HVAC curb flashing, parapet details, and accessory damage were restored to the estimate

Code-related roofing requirements were included in the revised claim presentation